Rendered at 07:31:03 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Cloudflare Workers.
rappatic 11 hours ago [-]
Unfortunately the open nature of Wikipedia leaves it vulnerable to coordinated 'edit attacks' like this. Similar pro-Palestine cabals have launched efforts to rewrite important pages. In several cases, editors were banned without their edits being reverted [1]. Several claims were attributed to sources that didn't support said claims, and these claims remain in their articles due to a discussion moratorium.
The consequences of such biased editing (on both sides) are widespread, especially since LLMs now rely heavily on Wikipedia as an unbiased source.
Are we seriously referencing the ADL as a reliable source?
FatCat1979 7 hours ago [-]
ah, yeah, you're right. "TechForPalestine" is clearly going to be a relaible source.
slowin 7 hours ago [-]
Why wouldn’t it be? I would say any organization that’s pro-Israel (such as the ADL, to the extreme) is far less reliable than an organization fighting for human rights during an active massacre and ethnic cleansing of Palestinians.
rappatic 9 hours ago [-]
As opposed to this clearly AI-generated “Tech for Palestine” article?
I cited the ADL article because it’s the one that makes the rounds, but it’s basically just a summary of many prior reports. There’s a reason the editors in question were banned.
DANmode 7 hours ago [-]
> There’s a reason the editors in question were banned.
…
dghlsakjg 11 hours ago [-]
> Several claims were attributed to sources that didn't support said claims
I know that wiki politics make doing anything hard, but I wonder if a decision model like Jev could serve as a first pass validator for external sources. E.g. Pull the content of a cited source, and ask Jev to tell you if the source backs the assertion. Run that across every new assertion (and go through the old ones), and you end up with a list of assertions that need further investigation.
markasoftware 11 hours ago [-]
a large portion of the article OP linked directly addresses the ADL report you're linking.
nwah1 10 hours ago [-]
by addresses, you mean just says that it is false without any evidence.
Why are you citing the ADL? They are an extremist Zionist organization. From your post:
> ADL's recommendations below are addressed to the Wikimedia Foundation, to search engines and AI developers, and to policymakers and the public who rely on Wikipedia.
This is just extortion under threat of accusations of “antisemitism”. We as a society do not want the ADL dictating anything to our institutions.
kombine 9 hours ago [-]
Read the room. Citing ADL in 2026 is just cringe.
lincon127 4 hours ago [-]
Lol, referencing the ADL like it's a sane thing to do, nice one, bot.
quietBitshift 11 hours ago [-]
I find it difficult to take this report as an impartial investigation when it makes claims like this:
> In most countries, a library running a Wikipedia editing course would be benign, and even positive. However, Israeli participation in editing Wikipedia must be understood within the context of Israel’s 78-year occupation of Palestine [...] In this context, any initiative taken by Wikimedia Israel to contribute to Wikipedia should be considered an extension of Israeli propaganda.
lol I don't get the downvotes. Every country is allowed to host events including Israel and Palestine. Here are all the Palestinian events hosted by Wiki Palestine:
These courses must focus on creating uncontroversial content like photos or female historical figures. They cannot recruit people to vote in disputes rather than make actual contributions, like Tech 4 Palestine did.
fanwood 9 hours ago [-]
Then you are not familiar with the level of anti-Palestinian and outright genocidal propaganda that is pervasive in Israel
ChrisArchitect 11 hours ago [-]
Title is: Israel Is Attacking Wikipedia
kombine 10 hours ago [-]
Why is this flagged?
hirako2000 10 hours ago [-]
Because it's the "wrong" politics.
_DeadFred_ 3 hours ago [-]
Actually dang made it clear Palestine has a special carveout/thumb on the scale that other political discussions (and that the escalation of Russia's war on Ukraine wasn't given) don't get on hacker news.
Or just look further in this thread and which 'wrong think' is flagged dead by HN. Hint, it's the politics opposite of the main post.
nophonobaldi 11 hours ago [-]
[dead]
jswartz 11 hours ago [-]
Wikipedia's biases are a reflection of its editors, which is why I now only use it for math/science topics, not emotionally-charged topics.
Hopefully AI is smart enough to know potentially biased topics when it sees them, and provides all sides in its answers.
amriksohata 10 hours ago [-]
THis happens both ways, mods can you take down this clear political advertising
Wikipedianon 11 hours ago [-]
Lol that this report is from Tech 4 Palestine, the exact organization that got banned by Wikipedia's Arbitration Committee (supreme court) for trying to influence discussions by coordinating on Discord.
> The Arbitration Committee has reviewed a dossier of "Tech4Palestine" Discord server related evidence and has determined that, as of this time, the concerns raised have been adequately addressed. The evidence has been retained by the Committee to be used, if necessary, to corroborate additional evidence received. The editors who were brought up in the report are:
* Samisawtak (talk · contribs) - topic banned by ArbCom
* Isoceles-sai (talk · contribs) - Result of below
* ZionistHater (talk · contribs) - Blocked as WP:NOTHERE by Drmies
* Discourseofcourse (talk · contribs) - Blocked as WP:NOTHERE by Bbb23
It's telling they refute the ADL report (which is non-credible, written after the bans, and had no influence on this) and don't mention any of the other reports describing what they actually did.
8 hours ago [-]
ceejayoz 11 hours ago [-]
And you believe this is a one-sided phenomenon?
Wikipedianon 11 hours ago [-]
No. Go read up on Icewhiz and Norcal who have been doing the same shit from a pro-Israel POV for a lot longer, getting banned all the while.
All these hyperpartisan hacks hate Wikipedia or other sites that try to portray "both sides" and would rather break the system because they'd rather people only read propaganda.
DIE_DIE_DIE 11 hours ago [-]
The way Israel operates on social media seems almost 1:1 with the way AI pushers operate. Have the large AI firms hired Israeli PR operatives to run their social marketing?
CircuitSeuss 9 hours ago [-]
Yes.
inquirerGeneral 2 hours ago [-]
[dead]
likelybot 11 hours ago [-]
[dead]
stefantalpalaru 6 hours ago [-]
[dead]
calvinmorrison 11 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
gnabgib 11 hours ago [-]
That's not how flagging works on HN, you've enough karma to know
calvinmorrison 5 hours ago [-]
Found the agent
11 hours ago [-]
danielklnstein 11 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
happytoexplain 11 hours ago [-]
That's a pretty tepid example, frankly. Arguably that is a neutral definition of Zionism. And arguably it is not. Either way, it certainly doesn't represent unreasonable anti-Israeli sentiment to the degree you are implying.
When a ethnic/cultural/religious group of people have sins to be documented, it is an almost intractable problem how we describe those sins neutrally. But your example is comfortably within the window of reason, considering the problem space. Your conclusions are too dramatic, in this light.
danielklnstein 10 hours ago [-]
Zionism is core to the Israeli ethos - portraying it in a racist light akin to the redacted 3379 resolution, is not tepid.
The definition in the article was changed during the current war, I think we can assume that it was changed by non-neutral actors for non-neutral reasons.
> When a ethnic/cultural/religious group of people have sins to be documented, it is an almost intractable problem how we describe those sins neutrally.
Certainly, but labeling Zionism as a racist ideology, or labeling the loss of life in Gaza as an unequivocal genocide, is not even close to neutral. It's far from intractable to recognize that, and to fix it.
happytoexplain 10 hours ago [-]
I don't think the definition is necessarily racist, except in the casual sense where we tend to over-apply the word. Regardless, this seems like a semantic argument. Which is fine, I don't have a strong feeling about what exactly the word "zionism" maps to, but it does mean there is no "right" answer until usage dictates one, and clearly usage is in flux at this point in history.
danielklnstein 10 hours ago [-]
The point is not whether the definition is racist or not - that would indeed reduce the discussion to a semantic argument about the definition of what racism means, that's not the point.
Do you disagree with the notion that whoever changed the definition - and yes, it was changed - did so with the purpose of influencing public opinion against Israel? Do you disagree that the definition - as currently written - will tend to bias the reader against Zionism (and by extension, Israel)?
That's the core issue here.
ceejayoz 8 hours ago [-]
> Do you disagree that the definition - as currently written - will tend to bias the reader against Zionism…
Is that a problem with the definition, or present-day Zionism?
Should apartheid's definition be revised to avoid bias or influencing public opinion against the South African regime that put it into place?
danielklnstein 1 hours ago [-]
Again, that's not the issue discussed under this current article.
It seems like you yourself think that the definition should bias the reader against Zionism and Israel.
And given the fact that the definition was modified in this manner during the current war, it's clear that there are editors on Wikipedia with an anti-Israeli agenda. I think you'll agree that it's highly doubtful that whoever added that appendix to the definition did so for neutral reasons.
So clearly there's anti-Israeli editors on Wikipedia, with demonstrable and long-lasting changes to key articles done by those editors with the intent of influencing public opinion against Israel - so in the context of the current article, I would ask (1) why is it wrong for there to be a counterparty to those efforts and (2) where are examples of edits committed by pro-Israeli editors that were done to influence public opinion in favor of Israel?
ceejayoz 8 hours ago [-]
> Zionism is core to the Israeli ethos…
Can a nation not hold a racist policy in its core ethos? I can think of some relevant historical examples.
"Over 70 Percent of Israeli Jews Oppose Arab Parties in Government, Survey Finds"
danielklnstein 1 hours ago [-]
Your quote is totally irrelevant to whether or not Zionism is a racist policy - including Arab parties in the coalition is a political consideration. A key characteristic of the Arab parties is their priority of the non-Israeli Palestinian cause. And their lack of support for what most Israeli Jews consider to be necessary security measures.
If the Arab parties in Israel exclusively focused on the wellbeing of Israeli arab communities, and didn't function as a mouthpiece for what many Israelis consider to be the enemy - that 70 percent would go down significantly. Sure, it would never reach zero, like in any country there will always be racists and bigots, but it wouldn't be anywhere near as unanimous as it is right now.
Case in point, none of the Arab parties will openly call Hamas a terrorist organization - which most Israeli Jews consider to be fact. Whether or not you agree with that assessment, it should be clear why Israeli Jews would be reluctant for Arab parties to join a coalition during a time of war against said terrorist organization..
drenuyt 7 hours ago [-]
This is a political tautology. Anyone voting for a party is opposed to other parties being in government.
Now do a poll of Arabs who are happy with Jews being in government.
ceejayoz 7 hours ago [-]
> This is a political tautology. Anyone voting for a party is opposed to other parties being in government.
Coalitions are very common in parliamentary systems, including Israel's.
> Now do a poll of Arabs who are happy with Jews being in government.
Done! Per the article:
"According to the Democracy Index poll, 71.5 percent of the Jewish public in Israel oppose their inclusion, and 77 percent of the Arab public support joining the Israeli government."
spankibalt 10 hours ago [-]
> Another blatant example is how in several articles the loss of life in Gaza is labelled flatly and without qualification as a genocide.
That is nothing but cheap propaganda. The genocide, which you euphemistically characterize as "loss of life", is well documented, with citations sourced from many noted experts in the field. Same goes for your ridiculous whitewashing of Zionism as non-racist; interrogations of the racist nature, history, theory and practice of this ideology are the subject of many tomes.
kombine 10 hours ago [-]
> Another blatant example is how in several articles the loss of life in Gaza is labelled flatly and without qualification as a genocide.
Because it is genocide.
10 hours ago [-]
mpweiher 10 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
kombine 9 hours ago [-]
I don't know why you think citing two Zionists, who aren't even experts in the field, is a convincing argument. Most pre-eminent historians and scholars of genocide, including Israeli Jewish ones conclude it is genocide. Here are some of the names: Omer Bartov, Raz Segal, Amos Goldberg, Lee Mordechai, Schmuel Lederman, William Schabas, Ilan Pappe, Avi Shlaim.
And I'm not going to address the wall of text you wrote because none of it is relevant to the legal definition of genocide, which I'm sure you are capable of looking up.
happytoexplain 10 hours ago [-]
>What Israel did in Gaza may well go down in history as the most humane and precise urban warfare environment the world has ever known—the very opposite of genocide.
I have no motivation to label what they are doing as "genocide", but this seems flatly untrue. I'm a little astonished to see this degree of speech about such a complicated issue on HN (it brings to mind Trump's absurdist word choices).
spankibalt 9 hours ago [-]
It's just reheated, and oddly enough rather old, propaganda. Lots of German conservatives love this stuff, it's Staatsräson.
The consequences of such biased editing (on both sides) are widespread, especially since LLMs now rely heavily on Wikipedia as an unbiased source.
[1] https://www.adl.org/resources/report/damage-done-wikipedia-l...
I cited the ADL article because it’s the one that makes the rounds, but it’s basically just a summary of many prior reports. There’s a reason the editors in question were banned.
…
I know that wiki politics make doing anything hard, but I wonder if a decision model like Jev could serve as a first pass validator for external sources. E.g. Pull the content of a cited source, and ask Jev to tell you if the source backs the assertion. Run that across every new assertion (and go through the old ones), and you end up with a list of assertions that need further investigation.
> ADL's recommendations below are addressed to the Wikimedia Foundation, to search engines and AI developers, and to policymakers and the public who rely on Wikipedia.
This is just extortion under threat of accusations of “antisemitism”. We as a society do not want the ADL dictating anything to our institutions.
> In most countries, a library running a Wikipedia editing course would be benign, and even positive. However, Israeli participation in editing Wikipedia must be understood within the context of Israel’s 78-year occupation of Palestine [...] In this context, any initiative taken by Wikimedia Israel to contribute to Wikipedia should be considered an extension of Israeli propaganda.
https://techforpalestine.org/wikipedia-report-2026/section-3...
https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Wiki_Palestine/Activity_repo...
These courses must focus on creating uncontroversial content like photos or female historical figures. They cannot recruit people to vote in disputes rather than make actual contributions, like Tech 4 Palestine did.
Or just look further in this thread and which 'wrong think' is flagged dead by HN. Hint, it's the politics opposite of the main post.
Hopefully AI is smart enough to know potentially biased topics when it sees them, and provides all sides in its answers.
https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User_talk:%C3%8Fv...
> The Arbitration Committee has reviewed a dossier of "Tech4Palestine" Discord server related evidence and has determined that, as of this time, the concerns raised have been adequately addressed. The evidence has been retained by the Committee to be used, if necessary, to corroborate additional evidence received. The editors who were brought up in the report are:
* Samisawtak (talk · contribs) - topic banned by ArbCom
* Ïvana (talk · contribs) - banned by ArbCom
* Tashmetu (talk · contribs) - EC revoked, warned for violating ECR
* Isoceles-sai (talk · contribs) - Result of below
* ZionistHater (talk · contribs) - Blocked as WP:NOTHERE by Drmies
* Discourseofcourse (talk · contribs) - Blocked as WP:NOTHERE by Bbb23
It's telling they refute the ADL report (which is non-credible, written after the bans, and had no influence on this) and don't mention any of the other reports describing what they actually did.
All these hyperpartisan hacks hate Wikipedia or other sites that try to portray "both sides" and would rather break the system because they'd rather people only read propaganda.
When a ethnic/cultural/religious group of people have sins to be documented, it is an almost intractable problem how we describe those sins neutrally. But your example is comfortably within the window of reason, considering the problem space. Your conclusions are too dramatic, in this light.
The definition in the article was changed during the current war, I think we can assume that it was changed by non-neutral actors for non-neutral reasons.
> When a ethnic/cultural/religious group of people have sins to be documented, it is an almost intractable problem how we describe those sins neutrally.
Certainly, but labeling Zionism as a racist ideology, or labeling the loss of life in Gaza as an unequivocal genocide, is not even close to neutral. It's far from intractable to recognize that, and to fix it.
Do you disagree with the notion that whoever changed the definition - and yes, it was changed - did so with the purpose of influencing public opinion against Israel? Do you disagree that the definition - as currently written - will tend to bias the reader against Zionism (and by extension, Israel)?
That's the core issue here.
Is that a problem with the definition, or present-day Zionism?
Should apartheid's definition be revised to avoid bias or influencing public opinion against the South African regime that put it into place?
It seems like you yourself think that the definition should bias the reader against Zionism and Israel.
And given the fact that the definition was modified in this manner during the current war, it's clear that there are editors on Wikipedia with an anti-Israeli agenda. I think you'll agree that it's highly doubtful that whoever added that appendix to the definition did so for neutral reasons.
So clearly there's anti-Israeli editors on Wikipedia, with demonstrable and long-lasting changes to key articles done by those editors with the intent of influencing public opinion against Israel - so in the context of the current article, I would ask (1) why is it wrong for there to be a counterparty to those efforts and (2) where are examples of edits committed by pro-Israeli editors that were done to influence public opinion in favor of Israel?
Can a nation not hold a racist policy in its core ethos? I can think of some relevant historical examples.
https://www.haaretz.com/israel-news/2025-12-22/ty-article/de...
"Over 70 Percent of Israeli Jews Oppose Arab Parties in Government, Survey Finds"
If the Arab parties in Israel exclusively focused on the wellbeing of Israeli arab communities, and didn't function as a mouthpiece for what many Israelis consider to be the enemy - that 70 percent would go down significantly. Sure, it would never reach zero, like in any country there will always be racists and bigots, but it wouldn't be anywhere near as unanimous as it is right now.
Case in point, none of the Arab parties will openly call Hamas a terrorist organization - which most Israeli Jews consider to be fact. Whether or not you agree with that assessment, it should be clear why Israeli Jews would be reluctant for Arab parties to join a coalition during a time of war against said terrorist organization..
Now do a poll of Arabs who are happy with Jews being in government.
Coalitions are very common in parliamentary systems, including Israel's.
> Now do a poll of Arabs who are happy with Jews being in government.
Done! Per the article:
"According to the Democracy Index poll, 71.5 percent of the Jewish public in Israel oppose their inclusion, and 77 percent of the Arab public support joining the Israeli government."
That is nothing but cheap propaganda. The genocide, which you euphemistically characterize as "loss of life", is well documented, with citations sourced from many noted experts in the field. Same goes for your ridiculous whitewashing of Zionism as non-racist; interrogations of the racist nature, history, theory and practice of this ideology are the subject of many tomes.
Because it is genocide.
And I'm not going to address the wall of text you wrote because none of it is relevant to the legal definition of genocide, which I'm sure you are capable of looking up.
I have no motivation to label what they are doing as "genocide", but this seems flatly untrue. I'm a little astonished to see this degree of speech about such a complicated issue on HN (it brings to mind Trump's absurdist word choices).